How to Choose the Best Real Estate Agent in Castle Rock, CO

“As a first-time home buyer in Castle Rock, I wanted to make sure I chose the right realtor. After calling around to multiple agencies, I found that many just wanted to get me under contract quickly — they weren't transparent and felt more transactional than supportive, which isn't what I was looking for as a first-time buyer. After those conversations and further research, I decided to go local with a family-owned business with experience. I called the Thayer Group on a Saturday morning around 7 a.m. and received an immediate response from Susan about a house I wanted to see that weekend. Susan and her husband, Steve, scheduled a walk through of the property the very next day, and by 4 p.m. that Sunday, we were putting in an offer.We were able to secure the house through multiple rounds of negotiation at approximately 3% under asking by that Monday — especially impressive given that the home had been on the market throughout 2025 at $50K above its current 2026 re-listing price. Throughout the entire process, Steve took the time to walk us through every step as first-time home buyers, investing hours over the phone and in person to help us meet contract deadlines and feel confident doing so. If you're looking for transparency, a personal touch, efficiency, a clear understanding of the home-buying process, and a genuine friendship with your realtor, go with the Thayer Group. I promise they won't disappoint.”

“We loved working with the Thayer Group to buy our first home. Cooper clearly explained the mills topic in Castle Rock (something totally foreign to us before this process). The whole family was fun and easy to work with. They fit tours around our busy schedule, showing us tons of homes across the area. Recommendations matched our priorities perfectly. Super knowledgeable on every tour and the market. Highly recommend for Castle Rock buyers.”

“We had an amazing experience working with Steve Thayer. After a frustrating situation with a previous realtor, we were nervous about starting the process again, but Steve immediately put us at ease. He was knowledgeable, professional, and extremely familiar with the Castle Rock market. Steve always answered the phone when we called, kept us informed every step of the way, and made the entire process smooth and stress-free. If you want to sell a house in Castle Rock, he’s the best. We truly felt like we were in good hands from start to finish and couldn’t have asked for a better realtor.”

“My wife and I sold our house in Castle Rock with Steve and his team. We chose their group because Steve was honest with us from the start. He gave us great guidance and helped us sell our house for more than we expected, and way quicker, too! They were all amazing and really made us feel like we were in good hands. Which we proved to be! If you're selling or buying your home in Castle Rock, do yourself a favor, pick Steve and The Thayer Group.”

“I HIGHLY recommend the Thayer group! They were incredibly helpful from start to finish. As a first time homebuyer and someone entirely new to the area I was very anxious about the whole process, but Susan and Steve eased my worries and helped me through every step. They were able to help me get an AMAZING deal while also introducing me to the Castle Rock community.”

“We have worked with The Thayer Group for 5 years now. Initially, a new home purchase in Colorado Springs during the pandemic and then a relocation to Castle Rock. They expertly guided us through all three transactions and were extremely pro active in avoiding any potential problems. We were very pleased with the "hands on" attention we received and would unconditionally recommend them to any potential clients. Orv and Enid Lewis”

“We recently made a move from Southern California to Castle Rock CO. Our Lender set us up with Steve and Susan Thayer of the Thayer Group. Even though we were not positive we were going to make the move, Steve and Susan spent three days driving us around in the snow looking at homes. When we made the decision to actually commit and move, Steve and Susan spent another two days with us and found us our dream home. They were fantastic throughout the process, and after we closed as well. It's not easy to find and buy a home from 1200 miles away, and the Thayer's made the process seamless for us. We highly recommend The Thayer group for all your Real Estate needs! Kevin and Dawn Sanderson”

“Steve Thayer of Keller Williams in Castle Rock is THE BEST BROKER EVER . He listed my house in Crystal Valley & helped me find a bigger home in Crystal Valley- He & his agents helped me sell the home by staging the house, holding open houses & just holding my hand along the way. He was ALWAYS there from day One thru the closing PLUS I got a FREE 7 day rent back - List with Steve - 💯 % Satisfaction Guaranteed ❤️😊”

“I would highly recommend working with the Thayer Group. We had a wonderful home buying experience with them. They were always available to show us houses when we needed, we’re patient with us in our long search and extremely knowledgeable in the castle rock area where we bought our home.”

“If you are buying or selling in the Castle Rock area, then The Thayer Group is who you want to contact. They are professional, knowledgable and sincerely care about you and your community. They will take the time to really listen to you and then will work in your best interest to achieve that goal. Highly recommend!”